Skip to main content

We didn’t need Hollow Knight: Silksong in 2024

Key art for Hollow Knight: Silksong.
Team Cherry
3D renders of video game controllers and devices.
This story is part of our 2024 in Gaming series. Follow along as we reflect on the year’s best titles.

Metroidvania fans like myself spent all of 2024 impatiently waiting for Hollow Knight: Silksong, but we didn’t really need to.

Take a step back, and you’ll see just how good of a year 2024 was for the Metroidvania genre even without that one game. From the AAA space with Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown to the indie scene with games like Nine Sols, many fantastic games dropped in this well-trodden platforming subgenre this year. You’re doing yourself a disservice if you aren’t checking out other well-made Metroidvania tiles while you wait for Team Cherry to drop the game it has been teasing since 2019.

Hollow Knight: Silksong - Xbox Game Pass Reveal Trailer - Xbox & Bethesda Games Showcase 2022

I do not doubt that Team Cherry’s long-awaited sequel will be a monumental release, but we shouldn’t use that as an excuse to ignore how the genre evolved over the course of the year. It’s misguided to place all your opinions on whether a year was good for games on a single title. The video game industry is much too diverse and flush with options for that — and 2024 proved it.

Recommended Videos

The many Metroidvanias of 2024

The original Hollow Knight is considered one of the best Metroidvanias of all time. It sported gorgeous visuals, had a lot of intriguing lore to dig into, gave players a massive and secret-filled world to explore, and featured silky-smooth platforming. No matter which of those things about Hollow Knight you liked the most, some new Metroidvania game this year appealed to that sensibility.

Want to play a game with gorgeous art? Look at the stunning animation of Bo: Path of the Teal Lotus or the detailed pixel art of Gestalt: Steam & Cinder. Are narrative and action the most important elements of a Metroidvania for you? Then Nine Sols’ Taopunk world and deflection-driven combat create the Sekiro to Hollow Knight’s Dark Souls. And no Metroidvania this year captured the feeling of curiosity during exploration as expertly as Animal Well did.

NineSols - Console Release Date Trailer

Even those who prefer retro games were satiated this year with the Castlevania Dominus Collection. There are several other competent Metroidvanias that I could mention, like Biomorph, The Devil Within: Satgat, AWAKEN — Astral Blade, Yars Rising, or Pinball Spire. A quick look at the genre’s new and trending Steam page will show how many Metroidvania games are coming out every month. Hollow Knight: Silksong might not be out right now, but this genre is as lively as ever.

Coming for Hollow Knight’s crown

Of all the Metroidvania games that came out this year, one matches — and, in some areas, surpasses — Hollow Knight. That game is Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown. Released in January, this game brought the series back to its 2D roots while innovating in the Metroidvania space. The Lost Crown is a meaty adventure that takes upward of 20 hours to beat, and not a moment of that feels like fluff.

Combat is fast and snappy, sometimes feeling like a 2D version of Devil May Cry or Stellar Blade. Platforming is fluid, and Ubisoft wasn’t afraid to create some truly devious challenges that wouldn’t have felt out of place in a game like Celeste. Both benefit from the Metroidvania formula as their complexities deepen as players acquire more abilities. On top of all that, it’s also incredibly approachable.

Prince of Persia The Lost Crown - Reveal Gameplay Trailer

There are tons of difficulty and accessibility modifiers, and a Memory Shard system allows players to take screenshots of important locations and pin them to a map so they don’t forget where to go next. Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown gives Hollow Knight a run for its money as the best recommendation for someone’s first Metroidvania. The base game and its DLC provided some of the most fun I’ve had in video games this year, and I can’t imagine not having played it because I just wanted to wait for Silksong.

It’s always a good year for games

There’s a takeaway in all of this. Whenever a highly anticipated product takes a long time to come out, the noise surrounding the hype for it becomes deafening. Right now, Hollow Knight: Silksong is right up there with Nintendo Switch 2 and Grand Theft Auto 6 as the biggest culprits of this in the gaming space. Of all those titles, the hype for Silksong can be the most damaging because it takes away attention from other indie games and other standout Metroidvanias.

Check the chat of every gaming showcase for the past couple of years and you’ll find at least a few people spamming it with pleas for Silksong. Those fans can sometimes tune out announcements from indie-focused presentations like the Triple-I Initiative Showcase because Silksong didn’t appear. Games like The Lost Crown seemingly underperform and don’t get sequels, while some Metroidvania fans act like Silksong is the only upcoming game in the space that matters.

Hollow Knight: Silksong Gameplay - Nintendo Treehouse: Live | E3 2019

None of that is Team Cherry’s fault; the studio should take as long as it needs to craft an unforgettable experience. It’s also OK to be excited about Silksong. I’ve just found myself disappointed in people saying 2024 has been a weak year for games because it didn’t have as many high-profile game launches as 2023 did or 2025 will. The situation with Silksong and the Metroidvania genre in 2024 is a microcosm of that.

The next time you’re about to beg for Hollow Knight: Silksong in a showcase chat, maybe head over to Steam and see if there’s a new Metroidvania title that you’re interested in playing there.

Tomas Franzese
A former Gaming Staff Writer at Digital Trends, Tomas Franzese now reports on and reviews the latest releases and exciting…
Samsung just slashed the price of this 49-inch OLED G9 gaming monitor by $700
A view of the Samsung Odyssey OLED G9 G95SC that lets you see its curve.

If you need to replace your gaming monitor following an upgrade from gaming PC deals, we highly recommend going for the 49-inch Samsung Odyssey OLED G9. It's originally pretty expensive at $1,800, but a $700 discount from Samsung itself drops its price all the way down to only $1,100. This display will do justice to your new computer's processing power, but you need to hurry if you want to get it for a lower price than usual because there may not be much time left before the savings disappear.

Why you should buy the 49-inch Samsung Odyssey OLED G9 gaming monitor

Read more
Winter Burrow finds the cozy middle ground between Don’t Starve and Mouse Guard
An owl attacks mice in Winter Burrow.

When it comes to survival crafting games, ambitious 3D sandbox games like Minecraft, Rust, or Valheim are often the first titles to come to mind. That said, I've often found myself just as entertained by the strain of survival and crafting games inspired by Don't Starve. While Klei Entertainment's 2013 indie classic is pretty hardcore, a lot of games inspired by it have been more cozy in nature. I have an enjoyable time relaxing, exploring cute worlds, and crafting items in games like Bandle Tale: A League of Legends Story or Cozy Grove.

Now, Pine Creek Games' Winter Burrow will fill the cozy survival-crafting void. At a recent ID@Xbox digital event I attended, Pine Creek CEO and Creative Director Benjamin Salqvist wasn't shy about bringing up survival games like Don't Starve, but emphasized that Winter Burrow will be a less stressful, more laid-back take on that formula.

Read more
Moonlighter 2 is a more ambitious sequel to a fantastic indie game
The shop in Moonlighter 2: The Endless Vault.

Moonlighter was one of 2018's best indie games. It realized a concept that felt so obvious it was shocking no one had done it that well before: go out and explore dungeons to find loot to sell in a shop players manage. It's a game I'd still highly recommend to fans of 2D action dungeon crawlers, roguelike fans, or shop management game fans to this day, and also one I'm eagerly awaiting a follow-up to.

Developer Digital Sun Games took some time away from Moonlighter to create The Mageseeker: A League of Legends Story and Cataclismo. However, the studio confirmed last December that it is making a 3D sequel to Moonlighter. Titled Moonlighter 2: The Endless Vault, I recently saw this game in action and asked a developer some questions at an ID@Xbox roundtable.

Read more